← 論文一覧に戻る

取締役会の女性比率とESG格付機関間の評価乖離:S&P500企業における取締役会の年齢と規模の調整効果

Women on Boards and Interagency ESG Rating Dispersion: The Moderating Roles of Board Age and Size in S&P 500 Firms (原題)

Nitin Kumar Jain

Business Strategy and the Environment📚 査読済 / ジャーナル2026-11-15#ESG経営インパクト: 資金調達対象セクター: cross_sector
DOI: 10.1002/bse.71726
原典: https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.71726

🤖 gxceed AI 要約

日本語

S&P500企業の2015〜2022年パネルデータを用い、取締役会の女性比率がBloombergとRefinitiv間のESG格付乖離とどう関連するかを分析。女性比率が高いほど格付乖離が小さい一方、取締役会の規模が大きい場合や平均年齢が高い場合にはこの効果が弱まることを示す。年齢による調整効果は従来の想定に反する結果である。

English

Using S&P 500 panel data (2015–2022), this study examines how board gender composition relates to interagency ESG rating dispersion between Bloomberg and Refinitiv. Greater female board representation is associated with lower dispersion, but larger and older boards attenuate this effect. The age moderation runs counter to conventional assumptions, highlighting firm-level governance determinants of ESG signal coherence.

Unofficial AI-generated summary based on the public title and abstract. Not an official translation.

📝 gxceed 編集解説 — Why this matters

日本のGX文脈において

SSBJ基準・有報でのサステナビリティ開示が進む日本では、ESG評価機関間の格付乖離は投資家対応上の実務課題。取締役会の多様性・規模・年齢構成が評価の一貫性に影響するという知見は、日本企業のガバナンス設計と統合報告書の説明責任に示唆を与える。

In the global GX context

As ISSB/CSRD disclosure regimes expand, interagency ESG rating dispersion is a recognized challenge for investors and regulators. This paper adds firm-level governance determinants—board gender diversity, size, and age—to the literature on ESG signal coherence, relevant to global debates on rating reliability and corporate governance quality.

👥 読者別の含意

🔬研究者:取締役会属性がESG格付の一致度に与える影響を実証した、コーポレートガバナンスとESG評価の交差領域への貢献。

🏢実務担当者:取締役会の多様性と構成がESG評価の安定性に影響しうるため、投資家向けESG説明の一貫性確保にガバナンス設計を活用できる。

🏛政策担当者:ESG格付のばらつきは規制上の課題であり、企業のガバナンス構造が評価の整合性に寄与する点は、格付規制や開示制度の議論に示唆を与える。

📄 Abstract(原文)

ABSTRACT This study examines the relationship between women on corporate boards and the consistency of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) evaluations across rating agencies, while recognizing that ESG rating divergence also reflects methodological heterogeneity across rating agencies. Although prior research has predominantly focused on ESG disclosure scores from individual raters, divergence in ESG scores across agencies for the same firm, referred to as interagency ESG rating dispersion, represents a critical challenge for stakeholders seeking reliable sustainability assessments. This study extends existing literature by analyzing firm‐level governance mechanisms as determinants of such a rating misalignment. Employing panel data from S&P 500 firms for the period 2015–2022, the analysis investigates how board gender composition is associated with interagency ESG dispersion between Bloomberg and Refinitiv, and how board size and average age moderate this association. The study draws on upper echelons theory and the attention‐based view to interpret the mechanisms through which board characteristics are related to the coherence of ESG signals communicated to external stakeholders. The findings indicate that greater representation of women on boards is associated with lower ESG rating dispersion, consistent with greater interpretive convergence across agencies evaluating firms' sustainability‐related disclosures. However, larger boards and boards with older members attenuate this effect. Notably, the moderation by board age runs contrary to conventional assumptions, suggesting that boards with older directors may constrain the alignment of ESG evaluations. This study contributes to ESG and corporate governance literature by emphasizing firm‐level determinants of rating coherence and the conditions under which board composition affects the interpretability of sustainability information.

🔗 Provenance — このレコードを発見したソース

🔔 こうした論文の新着を逃したくない方は キーワードアラート に登録(無料・3キーワードまで)。

gxceed は公開メタデータに基づく研究支援データセットです。要約・翻訳・解説は AI 支援で生成されています。 最終的な解釈・検証は利用者が原典資料に基づいて行うことを前提とします。